22 Comments
User's avatar
Chuck Pezeshki's avatar

Great piece. One of the things I've seen, though, is a re-definition of kindness. Which then will very likely lead to regulations about it, and persecution in the name of social order. Lots of folks running around saying "be kind" rarely are. It becomes another behavioral blanket enforcement process.

Peter's avatar

My parents are Polish and I ended up living in Poland for a few years. It was 8 years after the fall of communism.

If you were applying to university during the communist era, you would get bonus points on your admission exam that rewarded your “social origin” and/or what your parents did (eg were military). They would also reserve a percentage of spots for the preferred classes (these were groups that were historically marginalized, like farmers). Sound familiar?

Within a couple of generations Poland’s top institutions were full of incompetent, resentful people. As in the article, they also enjoyed special privileges that were not extended to the common citizen, and instead flaunted.

A similar approach was applied when allocating housing and cars - both were in short supply.

Many people had money, but there was nothing to buy, so it was effectively worthless.

Communism promised “beauty” as they were not focused on money like greedy capitalists. When I was living there, there was a lot of ugly and a lot of environmental disregard. When I visited this past spring, things are much different. It’s the “greedy capitalists” that introduced new, interesting architecture, art and cleaned up the environment.

They promised equality, but what they delivered was a hierarchy that was reorganized. The loyal party members were at the top, the intellectuals were executed (Katin massacre). Being “special” was disincentivized. “Everyone” earned the same salary… so nobody bothered to distinguish themselves. Many just drank. There was a rhyme in Polish, translated: “Whether you stand or whether you lie down, two thousand is owed to you.”

It took 30 years for Poland to recover from the damage caused by communism on the Polish psyche. Prior to that, it took 40 years of struggle to liberate itself from Communism.

Anti-Hip's avatar

"... Within a couple of generations Poland’s top institutions were full of incompetent, resentful people."

Thank you for your account here. On the surface, it looks like societal suicide. But I'm confident the orchestrators knew exactly what they were doing, as unseen real power always fills the apparent vacuum, while the lack of sunlight feeds their worst impulses and excesses, vs the needs of the population. Otherwise, when a power vacuum does not get filled, the structure literally crumbles and is overtly taken over instead.

I won't name names how this (currently of a lower-grade variety) already occurs in the U.S. except to say that it now occurs everywhere, and has been growing over the decades. Among elected officials it has nothing to do with the supposed party affiliation, except to keep the charades plausible.

Tom Grey's avatar

It is false that both the Dem commie party and the MAGA Rep party are similarly corrupt with luxury beliefs & group think. It’s about 90% Dem. Reps not totally innocent, but Dems mostly guilty

Dr. Dre's avatar

I have only-ever been a Republican, since 1952, Eisenhower's first campaign, when I was 7, but feelings of disgust arise from time to time. My spouse and son don't help matters with their frustration, and our daughter has one of those stupid Black Lives Matter signs in her yard in a nearly all-white suburb. I recently found some snapshots of my front yard in an Ohio village where I had several W Bush signs set up on the state hwy leading into town. Remember the 2020 Presidential election?

Anti-Hip's avatar

I guess we can agree to disagree then. :) Whatever one's personal stance, I invite people to read as widely as practical both/all sides. There are hideous behaviors and skeletons in most everyone's, and every organization's, closets.

Anti-Hip's avatar

"First, Lao She did not commit suicide; that is a Taiwan fabrication. Second, his suicide can easily be explained by his bourgeois mentality. Third, in any case, the episode is pointless, so why harp on it?

"In other words: that didn't happen, it's good that it did, and why are you so obsessed with it? Western activists and ideologues still use versions of this tactic today."

Exactly. This is just one of the playbooks for the sophistry that I see as harder at work today in the U.S. than it ever has been. It's well beyond activists and ideologues, it's infesting government, schools, the media, and far more. Compared to what I recall of the truth battles of my youth many decades ago, lying has effectively been normalized. I consider *the* most important single issue of the modern West, yet so few acknowledge it as a foundational problem.

Shawn's avatar

I found this to be a disturbingly sober and important post: Which is to say, nice job!! I'm not sure if this is restricted to subscribers only, but if so I suggest you think about making it generally available and maybe even promoting it on X or other channels you may utilize.

Dr. Dre's avatar

This post was OUTSTANDING! I am forwarding it to a number of people who NEED to read it.

Patricia Gibson's avatar

Thank you for this wonderful article. I appreciate the naming of what I am seeing today.

Nutmeg2020's avatar

Fantastic article!

P.J. DiMaria's avatar

Rob,

Just curious if you know about the 20th century Catholic Archbishop Fulton J. Sheen who was considered the foremost authority on Communism in his time?

Dion's avatar

Spot on. The “party” leaders of today, over educated elites, desire to be the leaders on the new regime. While talking about equality, the way they live and will rule is quite the opposite.

Marion Moore's avatar

Rob, I really enjoy reading your articles. But, it is disappointing to know that you are still a contributing writer at the Free Press which, as you surely know, is run by a hard core zionist who practically celebrates the genocide taking place in Gaza. Talk about not being kind...

Dan SG's avatar

A very good and concise presentation of Mao-ism that was as bad, or worse than the Stalin-ism. It is a fact that Mao went to Stalin, and got many miserable ideas from him.

I lived 35 years in the Socialist, that later, turned into a fake-Communist system. The Socialist thinking is : “I seek justice forever for the people I would, somehow, forcefully socialize,” and the fake-Communist thinking is: “We are all equal, but some are more equal than the others.”

In the Marxist theory there is not an easy transition from the Capitalist society to a Communist society other than the class warfare which is done by the Socialists. The Socialists would not start their system like a revolutionary movement without engaging first the Anarchists like a Trojan Horse. By the way, few of the German anarchists in Marx times have died here in this country.

The Western Elite has been promoting the Socialist and Communist ideas for over a century first in Europe in places like the School of Frankfurt, and the Fabian Society. At that time, such ideas were imported here, from Europe, by the kids of the American Elite studying abroad. They reached high, decision making, positions in the government and corporations.

The dream of the Western Elites is to have a smooth transition from the serfdom of the Capitalism to the serfdom of the Communism, without that violent step of the forced socialization done in a the most brutal way by the Socialists. The Elites have been founding, and god-fathering the revolutionary actions not the masses that are poor and disfranchised. They have a limited role, and later, when are no longer needed, they are violently suppressed like the old class that it is in the process of elimination. Lenin, Trotsky, the Bolshevik Politburo, and Mao were not poor at all.

The Socialist is constantly seeking justice even when the opposition is totally suppressed, if not demised. The true Communist has only Utopic egalitarian ideas, and it is vastly different that the Socialist turned into a fake-Communist that is seeking an affluent life as a compensation for the scarcity he endured during the class warfare. Mao as a ruler, had a lavish life, and a lot of concubines.

The former Socialist, now a fake-Communist, will always kill the true Communist because he will criticize the new opulent life full of debauchery. This is why Mao killed all the Communist dreamers like Lao She, Lu Xun, Wang Shih-wei and others from the “Let hundred flowers bloom” movement who sympathized with the masses that were mistreated in the most horrible way.

In conclusion, there are no two ways about… and as one said well: “If Marx was a scientist he would have tried it first on rats.”

Dan SG's avatar

Thank you for the likes. Like this article, my comments did not even scratch the surface of the subject. From 1950 to 1964, anyone including my parents could, at any moment, to disappear in the gulag system. My parents lost some friends, and the people they knew, to the terror. One of the major social modifications is the fact that everyone becomes a survivalist, and is frightened mostly of the relatives and close friends. Anyone could be a tale teller... There was no time for trust, and the kindness was totally excluded.

Gut Check Guy's avatar

🔷 Really strong piece, Rob. Your closing thesis hits: every social order gets the character it rewards—and, as your examples demonstrate, punishes.

What if we understood reward and punishment not merely as social incentives, but as developmental forces?

Your examples of resistance point to the other half of the equation: our developing capacity to withstand those forces.

The Q I’m working on: what develops the kind of person who can resist what their environment is teaching them to become?

Peter's avatar

The other observation I have from that era, and one I remember other expats having, is that people were often viewed as a nuisance. I think this ties into the article, and I wish I had included it above.

I noticed two broad groups of people around that time:

One group was trying hard to adapt and embrace the new opportunities. They generally worked very hard and took risks to achieve success (e.g. taking loans, which many in Poland feared). Many did very well.

The other group had become comfortable with the expectations of the previous system. They had difficulty connecting effort, innovation, creativity and risk-taking with success. They kept feeling that they deserved a flat, car and holidays, regardless of what they produced or the effort exerted. They also had a different concept of what "effort" and "work" meant.

One byproduct of this second group is that people were viewed, somewhat, as a nuisance.

For example, I remember shopkeepers, and even doctors, who would get blatantly annoyed by customers (or patients) coming in. These were often shopkeepers/grocers who worked in the same shops that traditionally hosted "bread lines", etc. during the communist era. "What do you want?" and "I don't have" were very common phrases from this group and delivered as though the customer was creating an inconvenience for them.

At that same time, the other group was growing and they were hustling.

I remember buying one of those small Aiwa bookshelf stereos that were popular at the time. A young man (late 20s) had opened up a shop out of the basement of his apartment block. He offered the best price in the city, so I bought the unit from him.

I didn't have a car and was bussing everywhere. He saw that I was trying to figure out how to get these boxes home when he said to me, "I can deliver for free".

Obviously, I am not suggesting that the above were universal rules. There were exceptions, but it was a clear pattern. If you were going to be ignored, it would rarely be by someone who was grinding to build something.

Social interactions were a bit different, but it makes me wonder about how much of that (if any) spilled over from business life into social settings? Perhaps the situation is now reversed? But I didn't notice anything like that a few months ago.

Ultimately, I am not sure it matters whether his kindness was entirely spontaneous, whether it was motivated by buying the stereo, or perhaps he felt some pride that someone had chosen his shop to buy something. It was kind of him to notice I had a problem and he helped solve it.

That seems to me to connect neatly with the passage about nurturing kindness in the article.

ru's avatar
Oct 14Edited

I grew up singing songs and saluting Mao as part of the school system to revere him on a weekly basis. In some ways, it was comforting to revere an adult as a child. They made him feel like a teddy bear grandfather for us. He had a santa claus aura.

Once I left that environment, it took me another 20 years to unravel my belief system around good intentions and bad outcomes. And that when humans get stuck, humans look for easy comfort without knowing when to stop indulging. I can see that pattern becoming a trend again.

The cost of being a 'bad guy' to challenge kids on being nice vs being kind is something no educational system or parents want to bear.

CP's avatar

I'm really glad to see this because Simon Leys (or Pierre Ryckmanns) is a terribly overlooked writer. I haven't in fact read this one on China, but I do have somewhere on these shelves the NYRB Classics edition of his wonderful collection of essays called The Hall of Uselessness. He was a great literary critic as well, and took Christopher Hitchens to task for his attack on Mother Theresa.

On the subject of NYRB Classics another view from inside a totalitarian system which must be recommended is Diary of a Man in Despair by Friedrich Reck, a very right-wing German who despised the Nazis. They discovered his diaries buried in his garden and took him away to a concentration camp. Somehow they were later published. A remarkable collection.